How Hard Is It to Replace Fireplace Mantel?

If you have ever thought about changing the look of your fireplace, you might have considered replacing the fireplace mantel.

But just how hard is it to do that? A fireplace mantel is a wooden or stone frame around your fireplace. Sometimes, you might want to switch it out to give your home a fresh new style.

We’ll take you through the steps to understand if replacing a fireplace mantel is a DIY project you can handle or if it’s better to call in a professional.

We’ll discuss the tools you might need and the materials required and offer tips to make the process smoother.

Whether you’re a beginner or just curious, you’ll have a good grab of how hard or easy it is to replace a fireplace mantel.

Gather Your Tools and Materials

Many tools on wooden table

To get started, you’ll need the following tools and materials

  • New Mantel
  • Screwdriver
  • Pry Bar
  • Hammer and Nails
  • Level
  • Measuring Tape
  • Power Drill and Screws
  • Wood Glue
  • Safety Gear

Step-By-Step Guide for Replacing Fireplace Mantel

1. Prepare the Area

A cozy living room with a fireplace and two chairs

Getting your fireplace ready for a project is simple. First, move any furniture or stuff away from the fireplace. This will give you more room to work and help avoid accidents. Next, protect the area around the fireplace.

Put down some sheets of plastic on the floor and walls nearby. This will catch any dust, ash, or mess that might fall during your project, keeping your floor and walls safe.

Lastly, don’t forget safety. Wear safety goggles and a dust mask to protect yourself from any dangers while you work. By following these easy steps, you’ll create a cleaner and safer workspace for your fireplace project—no need to worry about making a mess or damaging your home.

Now, you’re all set to make your fireplace even better.

2. Remove the Old Mantel

A man installing a fireplace in a living room, removing the old mantel.

To remove your old mantel safely, you’ll need a screwdriver and a flat pry tool. First, find any screws or nails holding the mantel to the wall. Use the screwdriver to unscrew them carefully. Once the screws are out, gently slip the flat pry tool behind the mantel.

Apply gentle pressure to separate the mantel from the wall. Be careful to avoid damaging the wall or the mantel itself.

Go slow and steady to make sure you remove the mantel smoothly without any problems. Being patient and gentle will help you take off the mantel without causing any harm.

3. Clean the Wall

A person cleaning a fireplace with a yellow cloth

After you’ve taken down the old mantel, it’s essential to clean up the area and remove any leftover stuff like paint or glue. You might need to do some light sanding or fix any small problems you find.

This cleanup step is important to make the surface smooth and clean for whatever you plan to do next, whether it’s putting up a new mantel or leaving the space as it is. So, take your time to make the area look nice, and you’ll be happy with how it turns out.

4. Install the New Mantel

Setting up your new mantel is as simple as following these steps to make sure it’s both safe and good-looking. First, you’ll need a strong board. Attach it to the wall using screws and anchors. This board is the base for your mantel. Next, gently put your mantel on top of this board.

Make sure it’s straight and level using a tool that shows you. Now, let’s make it secure. Use screws and a bit of wood glue to make sure the mantel stays in place. Check again that everything is firmly attached. Follow the maker’s directions, and remember that a straight mantel looks nice.

From aesthetics to safety, find out everything about fireplace mantel height in our comprehensive guide.

5. Finish and Decorate

Beautifully finished white fireplace complemented by a mirror

Once you’ve put the mantel in place securely, it’s time to make it look just the way you want. You can start by painting it your favorite color or using wood stain to give it a natural look. If you like decorating, you can add fancy stuff like trim or ornaments to make it special.

Or you can put your favorite decorations on top to show your style. You can be creative and make a mantel that fits perfectly in your space, making it your very own unique centerpiece that matches your home style.

Considerations and Tips

A white fireplace with a picture on the wall

When you’re setting up your fireplace mantel, take your time and be very careful. Safety comes first, especially if you’re using tools or working up high. If you’re unsure about something, it’s totally fine to ask an expert or search for how-to guides online.

Check your measurements twice before you start cutting anything. This means making sure your measurements are right before you grab those tools. So, don’t rush, stay safe, and be extra careful with your measurements to set up your fireplace mantel successfully.


Replacing a fireplace mantel is quite manageable, even for those with a limited DIY experience.

All you need are some basic tools, a bit of patience, and a clear plan to follow. Start by removing the old mantel carefully, then measure and choose a new one that fits your style and fireplace dimensions.

Mounting the new mantel can be done with screws and anchors, ensuring it’s level and secure. With some effort and resolve, you can change your fireplace and give your room a fresh, updated look.

Replacing a fireplace mantel is something you can do, and it can make your home feel even more comfortable.

Be sure to check out these other posts for more fascinating insights:

Benjamin Lee

Benjamin Lee earned his Bachelor’s in Mechanical Engineering from the Georgia Institute of Technology, focusing his 20-year career on heating systems and fireplace technology. He provides insights into modern fireplace innovations, installation guidelines, and safety practices. His prior experience includes working with home builders and fireplace manufacturers. His background includes engineering roles in HVAC and renewable energy companies. He enjoys woodworking and volunteering in environmental conservation efforts in his leisure time. He is also a winter sports enthusiast and advocates for eco-friendly living

Leave a Comment